Getting Funding
The method used to generate funds depends largely on how
the organisation will be perceived by potential donors, whether
individuals or institutions, as well as its ability to engineer
financial support through campaign successes and accountability and
trust.
Consumer organisations have traditionally adopted three models
to achieve financial sustainability: (1) membership contributions
(2) sale of magazines, publications and other derived products and
(3) grants from governments and external donors. Other alternative
income-generating initiatives are also now coming to the fore.
Membership fees
The most obvious source of revenue for most consumer
organisations is their members' ability to pay a small annual
contribution. This has also the advantage of providing an
unrestricted source of income though it is often not enough to meet
the minimal operating needs of organisations.
Recruitment of fee-paying members remains a challenge in many
developing countries where the provision of information services is
not seen as value for money by consumers. Many organisations do not
have the skills and capacity or an environment conducive to
developing a mass member base.
Product testing and publication
This model has been successful in Western Europe, USA, Australia
and New Zealand and continues to be robust there. Besides, the
testing and publication model has been implemented by consumer
organisations in Brazil, Russia, Thailand, South Korea, Indonesia,
Hong Kong and India.
Attempts to establish this model in
countries even with a sizeable middle-class have failed and many
organisations are struggling to sustain consumer information
services at a time when so much free material is available for free
on the Internet and through public information.
Successful product-testing
organisations are now extending this model
into providing multifold services and benefits to their members
through their online platform. This includes: access to archived
test results, podcasts on particular issues and exclusive video
content; access to online comparison/calculation tools and even
tailored testing service where members can request their individual
home, cars or kitchen appliances tested for asbestos, heavy metals,
etc.
Grant funding
This is by far the most prevalent model
relying on grants from foundations, private trusts, international
institutions, regional agencies, local municipalities, governments
and even universities. Even organisations who carry out product
testing and publish magazines combine this model to generate
funds.
In a number of countries governments
have come to play the role of a strategic ally for growth. However,
consumer groups should be wary of strings and risks attached to
receiving financial support from governments or private foundations
controlled by corporate interests who can damage their independence
or limit their ability to criticise.
In any case, it is recommended that
grants and subsidies should form part of a broader mix of
funding.
Additional initiatives
A few organisations are known to have
achieved financial viability via the model of cooperative
buying. This requires a strong grassroots network, proven
management skills and financial capacity, which few consumer
organisations have been able to acquire. Typically, basic-need
items such as staple foods are acquired in bulk by a network
comprised of several thousand families. A member will save about
15% to 20% on his household budget.
Attempts to replicate this model
elsewhere have generally not been successful. However, there is a
recent variation to this model: direct farmer-to-consumer organic
cooperatives are starting to enjoy a boom in developed countries as
an alternative model to supermarket-controlled and industrialized
food distribution and production.
Depending on the peculiarities of national legislations,
consumer organisations have also derived some of their revenues
from legal instruments. Court settlements such as
settlement money obtained through successful class-action suits are
to be highlighted here, particularly in North America. There are
also tax-free donations: in some eastern European countries, tax
payers are free to donate a percentage of annual tax to NGOs of
their choice.
In some cases, consumer groups have generated income through the
provision of paying services to consumers, local
governments and even businesses. Alternative Dispute Resolution
Centres handling and resolving complaints for consumers against a
nominal fee have proved a thriving model for organisations in
developing countries. Some organisations have engaged in the sale
of consumer data and analysis such as market data surveys and
consumer polls to businesses. Providing training on consumer
legislation for civil servants, council workers, businesses,
journalists and other NGO activists has also proved a successful
alternative.
Others
- Attendance fees and perdiems from meetings and seminars
- Speaker fees
- Fund raising event (organising a golf tournament or a gala
dinner for instance)
- Interest earned on financial investments
- Management of public/private compensation funds: fees earned
for managing financial protection schemes for holidaymakers when a
tour operator fails for instance.
Read more
For a useful resource about the development and implementation
of fundraising plans and strategies, read CI's manual 'The Management and Funding of Consumer
Organisations'